Today's news for the franchise & small biz owner

Log In / Register | Jun 18, 2013

9 Worst Industries to Start a Business

Data: SBA loan failure rate from 10/1/00-9/30/09 Chart/bmm

WASHINGTON D.C. — Video shops, electronics stores and bookstores have some of the highest failure rates, according to a report given to Blue MauMau by the Small Business Administration.The nine worst industries in which franchise establishments can be found include magazine distributors, electronics stores, video stores, and real estate offices.

No surprise there.

Neighborhood video stores have been disappearing, something Blockbuster franchisees have seen for themselves. The video store chain saw its establishments go from around 1,000 franchises in 2008 to 243, thanks to new technologies that have disrupted the old brick and mortar model. The franchisor is being auctioned off in bankruptcy proceedings in an effort to save the brand. Bookstores have franchisors too. Utah-based Beat the Bookstore sells college textbooks and Parable retails Christian books. Real estate firms franchise offices too. There's Century 21, Coldwell Banker Real Estate, ERA Franchise Systems, and more.

Here are nine industries in the worst 10 percent of the SBA list that have firms which franchise. Loan officers and business buyers realize that there are thousands of opportunities to buy and hundreds of other industries in the SBA list from which to choose, so why mess with those in the toughest categories?






NAICS Code & Description

Disb #

Disb $

(x $1000)

Failure %

ChrgOff %

#1. 452112--Discount Department Stores

91

$9,461

40.66%

15.07%

#2. 424920--Book, Periodical, and Newspaper Merchant Wholesalers

124

$21,541

30.65%

2.55%

#3. 443112--Radio, Television, and Other Electronics Stores

1,829

$270,556

26.79%

6.13%

#4. 451211--Bookstores

877

$98,566

26.34%

6.01%

#5. 511140--Database and Directory Publishers

236

$31,287

26.27%

3.39%

#6. 448210--Shoe Stores

1,143

$130,098

26.25%

6.01%

#7. 512120--Motion Picture and Video Distribution

131

$11,137

25.95%

3.78%

#8. 448110--Men's Clothing Stores

564

$68,007

25.89%

5.53%

#9. 531210--Offices of Real Estate Agents and Brokers

4,064

$613,978

25.32%

2.62%

The table explained

The Small Business Administration has provided to Blue MauMau its newest list of failure rates of small business loans from October 1, 2000 until September 30, 2009, sorted by NAICS industry codes. This is a collection of data from lendees on whether or not they pay back general SBA 7(a) and real estate and equipment 504 loans. Used by businesses to group businesses by economic activity type, NAICS is the North American Industry Classification System. For example, franchising is an industry, assigned NAICS code 533110.

The number of loan disbursements is listed, along with the disbursement figure, the percent that failed to pay back the loans, and the charge-off percentage (loss) to the lender. These figures help inform lenders and buyers on how well the small business establishments in an industry are financially able to pay back their small business loans. This is the list that the agency provides to loan officers of its most trusted lenders and banks throughout the country. The loans are guaranteed to be paid back to the lenders by the SBA.

No votes yet