Franchises Can Learn From Software Startups - Part 2: Trends
This article is the second of a three-part series related to technology in the franchise world. It discusses current trends in both the software and franchise worlds which are relevant, given the similarities illustrated in Part 1. Part 3 discusses what franchisors should be doing to react to this change in business context.
Fact: The world is changing. Technology is the catalyst.
The impact of technology on the way we do business is undeniable, and franchising is no exception. More often than not, franchise success stories list technology as one of the key elements to the franchise's growth. Five to ten years ago, most franchise systems recognized the value of a franchise intranet/extranet as a centralized franchise collaboration tool. More recently, the rise in franchise systems which allow absentee/semi-absentee franchisees has increased the need for software tooling that facilitates remote franchise management.
Start thinking about who will be buying franchises in the next decade or two. These people have grown up with the Internet and do not know life without it. A very insightful read on this subject is Diana G. Oblinger's recent publication Growing up with Google: What it means to education as many of the concepts can be projected from current day challenges in education to tomorrow's franchise sales situation. The Net Generation (born after 1982) is now entering the workforce with university degrees. It won't take long for them to look at purchasing a franchise. Thanks to the Internet, the Net Generation has access to vast amounts of information which doesn't always work in the franchisor's favor. A single individual can report scams which rapidly make their way through the Internet. There are even blogs dedicated to reporting fraudulent business opportunities. This generation has learned to question authority and to go the Internet to prove their claims.
The widespread availability of high-speed Internet has not only impacted franchise operations: it has deeply changed our society. The latest trends in software have been user-empowerment (blogs), online collaboration (wikis), and social networking (for business or for fun). In case you didn't know, over a quarter of all Canadians have a Facebook account. If you're thinking that this is a fad for kids and teens, think again as over half of these users are over 30. Reacting today to these social and technological changes does not only help prepare yourself for the future, it also helps you understand your current operating environment because the facts of life for the Net Generation are also true for many older individuals which are no longer marginal.
A few trends in the software world...
Starting a software company on a shoestring has never been easier for a number of reasons. First, high quality open source tools, powerful software frameworks, and the availability of free web services allows competent software engineers to solve problems faster than ever. Second, infrastructure costs are negligible. Everyone already has a computer and an Internet connection... and working from home is an option for MicroISVs. Once you outgrow your basement or garage, co-working environments provide an affordable way to grow your company to the next level. Even if you operate from home, you can still reach a very wide potential client-base thanks to the Internet and the same logic applies to any kind of business, not only software.
Another trend in the software world is that many cities (examples: Ottawa, Montreal) offer a vibrant software startup community which most people aren't even aware of. Founders are connecting and publicly sharing lessons learned. Funders are even connecting with founders at informal social events focused on growing the community. Twenty years ago, it would have been hard not only to meet startup founders but also to sit them down to hear about their experiences. Today, you can read about it on blogs and join up at local events... and if you're feeling old school, you can still buy books to learn the stories of other founders. As we all know, the Internet makes it easy to contact other people and collaborate online but it does also make it easier for people to meet offline for both business and social events.
Finding and retaining good people is the single hardest task in a software company, even if you've got money to burn. Money is an incentive, but is far from being the most significant one for software engineers. Indeed, just take a look at Maslow's hierarchy of needs to discover esteem and self-actualization are higher in the pyramid yet cannot be purchased with money. What developers are looking for are interesting challenges in a great work environment and most large organizations are unable to take advantage of this fact, which push the best software engineers to work at smaller startups or even start their own company. The best talent have plenty of opportunities to pursue and consequently don't often look for jobs on sites such as Monster whereas bad employees always end up unemployed and pollute the system. The solution in the software world is to be active in the software community and utilize niche-specific job sites such as the Joel On Software job board.
... That are also present in the franchise world
In the franchise world where we are seeing lots of concepts, such as home-based franchises, growing rapidly because of their low start-up costs. Many people dream of being their own boss while doing something they love and it now easier than ever for them to start their own business. Striking gold is (and always will be) hard, but one can make a decent living with a MicroISV (thanks to niche markets on the Internet) or home-based franchises (thanks to franchisors who know what it takes to make the concept work). We're also seeing an increasing number of new franchise concepts, partially because the Internet has made it easier to contact experts in franchising (and vice-versa... which is not always a good thing).
I would love to say there is a vibrant startup franchise community on the Internet, but that is simply not the case. There are a few disparate local associations but the web is polluted with franchise opportunity websites, given the high commissions related to franchise sales. However, if you look hard enough, you can find a few good websites which unite franchisees and franchisors under one roof for discussion and collaboration. Furthermore, younger franchisors are turning to blogs and are openly discussion various lessons learned. It would be superficial and discriminatory to claim age is the only factor at play to explain the slower growth of a good online franchise communities, but it is a contributing factor given the fact that franchisors require a substantial amount of capital to launch a franchise. Few, if any, current franchisors are part of the Net Generation. However, I am optimistic that a number of excellent franchise-related websites such as Blue Mau Mau, focusing on everything other than sales, will help grow the franchise startup community over the next decade thanks to collaboration between franchisors and various franchise service providers.
Finding and retaining good franchisees is an obvious challenge in the franchise industry. Many new franchise prospects are surprised that they are being screened for quality and are unaware that, for new/small franchisors, their individual success can have a strong impact on the success or failure of the whole system. Most franchisors complain about the decreasing quality of leads via franchise websites and this poor quality is surprising given the parallel which can be made with online recruiting systems such as Monster. As more people look for franchise opportunities on the Internet, it becomes increasingly important for franchisors to be able to efficiently filter through a larger volume of requests but also for them to be proactive about sales and marketing. This can be achieved by participating in online communities dedicated to their niche. Of course, time & effort is a valuable commodity and lower quality leads are to be expected when a franchisor doesn't proactively work on solutions on a daily basis.
Summary
After discussing changes in our society, this article covered three core trends:
- Younger people are starting businesses on a shoestring budget.
- It is easier than ever to connect with other people and learn from their mistakes.
- The big sites are saturated with people you don't want to hire or have as franchisees.
Part 3 will talk about what you should be doing to make the best of this changing environment. Your homework for the next week is to participate in a few online communities of your choice (Franchise, Startup, or Local). Also, take a look at Franchise NewsBlast, which we are launching today.
****
Jason Kealey is a founder of LavaBlast Software, a company that develops Franchise Software to simplify day-to-day franchise operations. This article was originally published on the LavaBlast Software Blog.
Related reading:












Internet Lead Flow for Franchisors
Jason,
Your parts 1 and 2 are interesting pieces and I think it's a creative comparison - software start-ups vs. new franchisors.
Based on this quote however: "Most franchisors complain about the decreasing quality of leads via franchise websites ...", you may be painting with too broad a brush. While you are right, most that use them complain, a growing number of franchisors are finding a better way.
There are too many advertising portals and most do a lousy job for too much money. They are way too expensive for value received. And you are also right in surmising that most franchisors are foolishly stuck in the mode of using these services.
But, for those sharp firms that use IT effectively, there is rarely a need to employ or pay for presence on those sites.For a few years now I have done battle on this front and have seen great results.
We're not all obtuse to present day tools.
Keep up the good work.
Internet Lead Flow
Sorry for the late reply, I was on a short vacation :)
I agree with you that this problem does not impact all franchisors and this series of articles is intended to be a "wake-up call" for the smaller franchisors that are not using IT effectively but can react quickly after learning a bit more about what's going on in the world today.
Thanks for your comments!
Jason Kealey
LavaBlast Franchise Software - http://www.lavablast.com
Franchise Owning IT Trends
Jason,
How do you think the IT trends you speak about will impact the franchise owner, as opposed to the operator of franchise chains? Emerging open source software?
How would cheaper IT city resources that few have heard about such as Nashua NH, Huntsville AL, Bloomington IL or offshore like Bangalore, India, Dublin, Ireland or Montreal, Canada affect franchise owner-operators?
I would dare say that nowadays just about everyone finds franchise opportunities through the Web. The current ad portals are not very useful tools for franchise buyers though.
Franchise Owning IT Trends
Franchisees need to be aware of these trends as they are responsible for bringing people into their stores. Regardless of the industry you operate in, there are web resources that everyone uses to find businesses. If you're not listed on them, you're losing out. As an obvious example, if your hotel is not on TripAdvisor, Expedia, and Google Maps, not many foreigners will plan to stay at your hotel during their vacations. You're responsible for putting pictures of your own hotel online so that people see the full picture, not just one bad review on a random site.
You can definitely see the same trend in any niche type business such as hobby shops, cigar shops, coworking environments, etc. Niche businesses attract people who want something specific, and these people go online to find stores which offer these specifics. Of course, the franchisor should be doing this work for you, but there are still hundreds of community-based websites which you may want to participate in as a franchisee to ensure your particular store is listed in the right places. Restaurants also need to be listed online because not everyone takes a walk down town and picks a random restaurant.
Depending on the crowd you're looking to attract, there are different places you need to be. I think the only exceptions that come to mind are high-volume, low-differentiation, high-impulse franchises. (hot dog stands, for example) For these businesses, location is key and no one really looks them up online.
As for open source, I can understand your concern. Open source can indeed impact your life as a franchisee and you can utilize it to cut down on costs or do more with your time. However, you're probably not a software developer and will probably not be modifying the code yourself. Therefore, the main advantage for you is that it is free and you have the source code available if you want to pay someone to adapt it for you. In some scenarios, you'll save a bunch of money. In others, it will cost you a lot more. You should trust a competent software engineer to help you with these decisions before starting any large software project, using open source software or not. I personally develop both open source and closed source software as both have advantages in certain contexts.
Let me explain my view of things. Software is a tool. Most software ends up being 80% context and 20% differentiation. 80% of the work we do as software engineers is putting pieces of software together so that we can support the 20% of features the client truly cares about. This 20% is custom for the client whereas the other 80% solves a generic problem and can be re-used in various contexts. For software engineers, open source software is a solution to avoid re-inventing the wheel for this 80%. For users, open source software solves certain problems and don't cost a dime up front. As a franchise owner, if you see a free service that does what you need to solve your problems (marketing campaigns, analyzing sales trends, etc.), why not use it? (it can be open source or simply an online free service).
As for outsourcing, this is again a double-edged sword in the software engineering world. Its greatest value is for the 80% context which doesn't differentiate the software from the competition. The remaining 20% should be done by domain experts that bring added value to the table. You need a good quality assurance process to outsource properly, but it should be invisible to the franchise owner. It is like asking how having your new VW made in Mexico rather than Germany impacts the franchisee: it shouldn't. Depending in which industry you operate in, outsourcing may impact the way you run your business or what your customers think of it.
As for finding franchises online, I feel there is a bit of both, but the Net Generation will definitely do lots of research online before attending a tradeshow (or afterwards, to evaluate alternatives).
Thanks for your comments and sorry for the late reply.
Jason Kealey
LavaBlast Franchise Software - http://www.lavablast.com